
In development
ReFood Community Certification
A future way for groups of farmers and food actors in a region to show, together, how their ReFood Community works across the five pillars, based on trust, peer review and learning.
Certification is in development. No ReFood Community is certified yet, and the criteria below are a draft for discussion.
What is a Participatory Guarantee System?
“Participatory Guarantee Systems (PGS) are locally focused quality assurance systems. They certify producers based on active participation of stakeholders and are built on a foundation of trust, social networks, and knowledge exchange.”
In a PGS, farmers, consumers and other local stakeholders check each other's practices and decide together. The core of the system is the peer review: farmers visit each other's farms, at least once a year, and learn from what they see.
IFOAM – Organics International describes PGS as alternative and complementary to independent third-party certification. PGS are designed to be affordable for smallholders, with paperwork that suits the farmers, and to build knowledge within the group.
A PGS is not the same as legal organic certification. In some places, including the European Union, products may only be sold as "organic" with third-party certification.
Data collected by IFOAM in 2022 counted at least 323 PGS initiatives around the world, with more than 1.4 million producers involved. Source: IFOAM – Organics International, PGS statistics.
Six key elements of every PGS
IFOAM – Organics International describes six elements that PGS around the world share. The ReFood certification will build on them.
Shared vision
The starting point. Producers, consumers and other stakeholders agree together on the principles that guide the system.
Participation
The people who produce and buy the food take part directly, share responsibility and are involved in every step, including peer reviews.
Transparency
Everyone knows how the system works: the standards, the review process and how decisions are made. The list of approved producers, and any sanctions, are public.
Trust
The approach starts from the idea that producers can be trusted. Members express this through a pledge or a group commitment.
Horizontality
No hierarchy: responsibilities rotate, producers review each other and everyone has an equal say in decisions.
Learning process
Reviews and meetings are moments to learn, both technically and socially. What the group learns improves the standards over time.
ReFood principles for certification
The ReFood Network remains the owner and steward of the international ReFood Community certification framework. The certification will operate through a Participatory Guarantee System. It must support continuous learning, shared responsibility, transparency and quality improvement, and should not simply function as a conventional external inspection or commercial certification scheme.
The future certification system should include:
- Shared standards and principles
- Participatory community evaluation
- Peer reviews and mutual learning
- Local stakeholder involvement
- Participatory field visits
- Transparent assessment criteria
- Documentation of progress
- Continuous improvement
- International consistency with local adaptation
How the five-pillar self-assessment works
The five pillars form the foundation of the assessment. Each farm, processor or distributor in a community scores its own practice, question by question. Together the scores show where a community stands, what is strong and what to improve next.
Who answers
- Farmer or grower
- Processor
- Handler or distributor
The questions depend on your role. A processor answers no questions about tillage; a farmer answers no questions about checking suppliers.
Every question is scored from 0 to 4
- Score 0: None, or harmfulNot in place, or the current practice causes harm.
- Score 1: Informal, occasionalDone sometimes, without a plan or records.
- Score 2: Partly in placeA plan exists and is partly followed.
- Score 3: Consistent, with recordsDone every time, and written down.
- Score 4: Measured outcomesResults are measured and used to improve.
Safety comes first
Some questions are critical: food safety, chemicals, animal welfare, worker safety and fair pay. A zero on a critical question is never offset by a good score elsewhere. It must be fixed first.
Honest gaps
"Not applicable to me" leaves a question out. "I don't know" counts as a data gap: finding out is the first step.
From scores to a plan
The result is a list of what to stop, what to improve and what to start. That list becomes the improvement plan the group follows up together.
Tracked over time
Assessments are repeated, so each community can document its activities and results and see its progress year after year.
The average score of all areas places a community in one of five stages of development:
- Initial
- Early adoption
- Developing
- Established
- Outcome-led
The draft questions
Open a pillar to see its questions and the first step to improve. These are a draft for discussion with communities and partners.
ProduceAgroecological and regenerative production: soil, biodiversity and safe practice.10 questions, 2 critical
How much of your land is covered by living plants or residue through the year?
First step: Add cover crops or mulch so soil is never left bare.
How do you manage tillage and soil disturbance?
First step: Move toward reduced or no-till and track soil structure.
How often do you test your soil and act on the results?
First step: Test soil every year and write a nutrient plan from the results.
How do you control runoff and erosion on and around your site?
First step: Add buffer strips, contour or drainage controls, and keep photos as records.
How diverse are your crops, livestock or varieties?
First step: Add one new crop, variety or rotation step each season.
How much habitat (hedgerows, trees, wetland, flowers) do you keep for wildlife?
First step: Set aside field margins or plant trees and flowering strips.
How do you manage pests while using fewer chemicals?
First step: Scout regularly and use biological or cultural controls first.
How safely do you store, handle and apply chemicals?
First step: Lock and label storage, train handlers, and keep application logs.
How well are animals cared for?
First step: Get an animal welfare check from a vet or accredited auditor.
How do you check that suppliers protect nature and land?
First step: Ask suppliers for land-use and sourcing evidence.
ProcessLocal processing, preservation and value creation, safely and with good records.5 questions, 1 critical
How well do you follow food safety and hygiene controls (HACCP, GAP or equivalent)?
First step: Get a qualified food-safety review and close gaps immediately.
How complete are your production and batch records?
First step: Use one simple log for dates, inputs, lots and outputs.
How do you trace products back to their sources?
First step: Label every lot and keep supplier records for each delivery.
How sustainable are your packaging and inputs?
First step: Switch to reusable or recyclable packaging and cut single-use inputs.
How do you track energy use and greenhouse gas emissions?
First step: Record fuel and electricity monthly and set one reduction goal.
EatReconnecting people with healthy, culturally appropriate, locally produced food.3 questions
How much of your food reaches people in your own region (local markets, shops, restaurants, schools or institutions)?
First step: List where your food goes today and choose one new local outlet to try.
How do you make sure the food you offer is healthy and fits local food cultures?
First step: Ask your customers or partners which foods they miss, and test one.
How do the people who eat your food get to know where and how it is grown?
First step: Organise one farm visit, market day or open day each season.
DonateFair access to nutritious food through redistribution, food rescue and solidarity.3 questions
How do you make sure good surplus food reaches people who need it, instead of being wasted?
First step: Agree with one food bank, social organisation or solidarity initiative how to pass on surplus.
How do you work with social organisations to improve access to nutritious food?
First step: Meet one local social organisation and ask what food they need most.
How do you record what you donate, and to whom?
First step: Keep a simple log of donated food by type, amount and recipient organisation.
CompostClosing nutrient cycles: less waste, more value, nutrients back to the soil.3 questions
How do you track food loss and waste at each step?
First step: Weigh and log waste weekly, by cause and step.
How do you reuse by-products, off-cuts and surplus?
First step: Match each by-product to a use: feed, compost, donation or processing.
How do you return nutrients to land through compost or digestate?
First step: Start a compost or digestion system and record what goes back to land.
Across all pillarsWater and climate, people and good governance: the foundations under every pillar.10 questions, 3 critical
How do you measure and manage water use?
First step: Meter water use and set a yearly reduction target.
How do you test the quality of water leaving your operation?
First step: Test discharge water and have a qualified expert fix any breach now.
How prepared are you for drought, flood or heat?
First step: Write a simple plan for the weather risks you face most.
How well do you protect worker health and safety?
First step: Do a hazard walk-through, fix top risks, and train every worker.
Do all workers get fair, on-time pay and safe conditions?
First step: Put pay and conditions in writing and check them against local law.
How do you train workers and support their growth?
First step: Run a short training each quarter and record attendance.
How do you work with your community and respect local knowledge?
First step: Meet neighbours and local growers twice a year and act on what you hear.
How do you keep financial records and plan costs?
First step: Track income and costs monthly and budget for the season.
How do you plan for risks like price drops, disease or lost suppliers?
First step: Write a one-page risk plan with a named backup for each risk.
Do you set sustainability targets and review them each year?
First step: Set three measurable targets and review them every year.
Steps for a group of farmers in a region
Setting up a PGS takes time, work and commitment, especially from producers. These steps follow IFOAM's guidance for implementing a PGS, adapted to the ReFood model.
START WITH A COMMUNITYUnderstand your region
Look at who is involved, what they need and can offer, the local rules, the market and how well people know regenerative practice. Talk to an existing PGS in a similar region.
Build a shared vision
Bring farmers, processors, consumers and local partners together. Discuss what everyone gains and agree on the principles you share, step by step.
Agree how your group will work
Write down, in plain words: the criteria, who does what, how decisions are made, what happens when something is not right, and what the system costs in money and time. Start simple and improve as you learn.
Learn the criteria and make a pledge
Train together on the five-pillar criteria. Each member then makes a commitment to the group, such as a signed or public pledge, and the group keeps a list of its members.
Self-assess and map each farm
Every member completes the five-pillar self-assessment and records a simple map and plan of their farm or operation.
Peer review visits
Members visit each other at least once a year, with the farmer present, using a shared checklist and a short written report. This is the heart of a PGS.
Decide together and keep improving
A group committee reviews the reports, agrees on improvement actions and approves members. There is always a way to appeal. Treat the first round as training.
Recognition by The ReFood Network, and how a community's status is published, are still being developed.
In development
Interested in ReFood certification?
Is your group of farmers or food actors interested in working with the PGS approach, or in helping to shape the framework? Let us know. We will keep you informed as the certification develops.
Sources
- IFOAM – Organics International: Participatory Guarantee Systems
- IFOAM – Organics International (2019): PGS Guidelines. How to develop and manage Participatory Guarantee Systems for organic agriculture
- IFOAM – Organics International: PGS statistics (data collected in 2022)
- The ReFood Network: first draft of the Regeneration Calculator (self-assessment), basis for the draft questions
Back to The ReFood Model.